I find one of the most obnoxious, frustrating parts of parenting a child with autism is vaccine-gate. I hate the whole topic. I don’t know where I stand on it. Know why? I don’t have time to read freaking medical studies. I’m too busy spending twice as much at the grocery store on his special diet (it’s working medical community) and patching the holes he puts in our walls with his head.
A year or so ago some family won a huge judgement validating that their daughter’s autism was partly caused by vaccinations, but within the last week some major paper linking vaccines to autism had to be retracted. I’d find the links to both stories, but I really don’t even care enough.
I care about one thing. I care about kids with autism, especially mine, growing up to live productive, happy, independent lives. I care about the general public understanding autism enough to celebrate the strengths and unique talents of autistic people and help them with their weaknesses.
I’m not even sure I want a cure. While I don’t believe my son was born with autism, I also don’t know who he would be without it. We’re grateful that many of his symptoms are things we consider talents. That’s why it took so long to diagnose him. He has talents in math and art that he simply wouldn’t have without autism. I’ve said (and taken heat for) before that if there was a magic pill that would reverse his autism I’m not sure I would give it to him. I believe in God. I believe God makes each human being a certain way for a certain purpose. I wonder if 20 years from now the world will face some challenge that only the mysterious minds of autistic people will be able to solve. Or maybe not. I don’t know and neither do you.
It seems like with every major medical issue with awareness, comes commerce. I believe the most vocal voices on both sides of treating autism are personally and professionally invested in “being right”.
Jenny McCarthy and her son Evan have become the faces of autism in America. I don’t necessarily agree with her, but I do think she is really misunderstood. The type of autism Evan has resulted in seizures. That was what led to his diagnosis. Imagine standing by helpless as your toddler experiences that. Evan had one seizure that put him into a coma. He almost died. That gets her a lot of slack with me. This goes way beyond lining up toys and not making eye contact.
I also think there’s a big misconception that Generation Rescue (Jenny McCarthy’s group) and those on the side that believe vaccines, specifically the preservatives in them, contribute to autism advocate stopping vaccinations altogether. I’ve never heard any serious person suggest that. What I have heard them say is that there should be a safer vaccine schedule and we should look at the various preservatives used in them. It’s not as simple as just mercury.
Then there’s the medical community. It goes pretty much like this: “I’m sorry ma’m, your son has autism. Just like that kid and that kid and that kid. We have no clue what causes it, but we know it sure as hell wasn’t anything WE did. Also, Jenny McCarthy is the devil. See ya’ in 6 months!” You’ll have to forgive me if I have trust issues with the medical community. Now my kid might also have ADD, and I get to go through all this again over Ritalin. That’s why mommy drinks.
Now the dialogue is constipated. I’m afraid McCarthy’s hostile approach towards the medical community has only made things worse. Is a cage match between a retired Playmate and representatives of the AMA and CDC on Larry King really helpful? It seems like emotions and pride got the best of everyone, they went to their corners and productive discussion ceased.
Meanwhile, parents, educators and hands on physicians have to figure out how to help these families just get through the day, literally. I think the last stat I heard was 1 in 86 boys in America will have autism. I find it difficult to believe the numbers skyrocket that much from a genetic cause or loosening of the definition of what autism is. There is something in our environment that is, at the very least, contributing to the epidemic. While Generation Rescue, Autism Speaks, the CDC, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the AMA, the local Elks lodge and Dr. Greg Gutfeld point fingers, thousands of families like mine are just trying to get through the day, heartbroken and confused. On behalf of families like mine, I kindly ask you to pull your head out of your ass, put on your big girl pants and figure out what we’re gonna do to make sure these brilliant children become contributors to society instead of drains on it. I think the latter would be the saddest thing of all.
[...] DON’T KNOW JACK 5 02 2010 On vaccine-gate. This is my other blog where I write about my son, Jack, who has autism. I usually try not to [...]
By: YOU DON’T KNOW JACK « KillTruck on February 5, 2010
at 7:13 pm
1 in 86? That’s insane! Seriously, I’m with you, I don’t know what to think about it. My little brother had seizures for the first 3 years of his life. Most of early memories were of holding him while he was seizing. The cure then was Phenobarbital which is a crazy strong barbiturate.
I am pretty sure that both of us would have been diagnosed with Autism, ADD, ADHD and every other label, had we been seen by doctors today. I guess I’m just lucky, I slipped through the cracks without getting a label attached to me while I was growing up.
You just go with what you got in this life, the best you can I guess.
By: Jason on February 5, 2010
at 7:13 pm
We also have an autistic son and your words resonate with me. Our son is very low-functioning but in a way that’s been helpful, because it opened the door to more understanding doctors and better medical treatments — treatments that ended years of violence directed at himself and us.
FWIW, I have a slightly different take on vaccines. Our son’s autism is related to a vaccine injury. We know this because the doctors have told us this, including doctors at the NIH. But his case is unusual because he had an underlying immune problem similar to the Bubble Boy Syndrome (medically known as X-SCID). He should not have been vaccinated because he has an impaired immune system — something that the pediatricians are supposed to spot and recommend against vaccinating — but it’s very hard for doctors to recognize this in infants and children because most babies have limited immunity. (That’s why they get sick more than adults.)
I favor antibody titer testing before vaccinating a child if parents have concerns about their child’s immune status. This tells us whether a child already has natural immunities to the diseases they are being vaccinated against. For instance, if the titers show a child already has sufficient antibodies to measles, you don’t need to vaccinate him/her for measles. This may make an adverse reaction less likely.
Sorry for getting on a soapbox but thanks for the chance to comment. Best wishes to you and your family. Like you, we believe in God and know He has a purpose for our lives and the life of our child.
By: Deb on February 5, 2010
at 10:03 pm
Thank you for the very informed comment. If parents of newborns were armed with this information they could make a more informed choice about vaccinations.
By: killtruck on February 5, 2010
at 10:44 pm
Wow. Thank you for saying that there has got to be something going on causing this spike in autism. I have two children somewhere in the spectrum, and while I’m certain genetics plays part of it (too many engineers in the gene pool), I don’t think that is the whole picture. Being an engineer, I don’t think things just “happen”, there’s a reason, and it appalls me that the medical community seems unable to step up to the plate to find out what is going on. I hope and pray you find the answers you seek.
By: Nancy on February 5, 2010
at 11:37 pm
There are SO not any engineers in our gene pool!
By: killtruck on February 7, 2010
at 12:45 am
Jack’s my man. I know you’ve seen a little twinkle in his eyes at times… that’s the tell that he’s got lots of cards he’s not showing.
I like to live with and love what I’ve got. Can’t change what God gives you.
By: Mark T on February 6, 2010
at 12:43 am
P.S. You & Nancy are also correct.
By: Mark T on February 6, 2010
at 12:47 am
My son also has autism. He was diagnosed at age 6. Every doctor missed it because he was so high functioning. A blessing and a curse. I have had a difficult time finding treatment for him because he isnt as bad as ‘the others.’ He is the greatest joy of my life and has gifts that we have not even been able to scratch the surface of yet. I could not agree with you more, stop trying to find a cure and focus on unlocking the brilliance that is hidden deep inside these wonderful children.
By: marie on February 6, 2010
at 1:39 am
Jack’s pretty high functioning too. He wasn’t diagnosed until age 5 because the only symptom was a speech delay for a long time.
By: killtruck on February 6, 2010
at 2:19 am
My son is also autistic, but he’s too early to say whether he’s high-functioning [he's above low-functioning, and no seizures or any real medical problems other than eczema, but our other kids have skin issues, too]. We caught it “late” at age 3, because we’re all a bit odd and thought boys generally develop slower than girls….and were apt to certain focus/obsession. there was no clear “break”, he was as he always had been. Many of his qualities are also seen in his sisters, but they function “normally” and don’t go to the extremes he does.
I’m pissed off at the whole vaccine brou-ha-ha, not because of my son [I was pissed off about the vaccine thing before he was born], but because I’m an actuary and I’ve seen mortality tables for children before vaccination.
People think it’s vaccinating against mere annoyances, but most of the childhood vaccines are against diseases that often resulted in death or lifetime disability.
Sure, I have no problem with wanting to change the timing of the vaccines, but eschewing them entirely has consequences in the population in general.
By: meep on February 6, 2010
at 6:15 pm
And my husband has been doing a lot of researching of trying various dietary treatments, and we’re up to stuff that, even if it doesn’t actually help, shouldn’t hurt. [such as fish oil] Like many, we’re wary of pharmaceutical interventions.
In addition, our son goes to a Fred S. Keller school, and though they’re not going to “cure” his autism, they do help him be more functional in the larger world. They use ABA [applied behavior analysis, I believe], which is a form of classical conditioning training applied to the specific situation of these kids — they’re taught to respond appropriately to their names, sit still, all of that — and using toys and food as reinforcers of the desired behavior.
By: meep on February 6, 2010
at 6:20 pm
I think we’re all trying to do what’s best for our children, but we also need to think about what’s best for future generations.
By: Deb on February 6, 2010
at 11:28 pm
How so?
By: killtruck on February 7, 2010
at 12:48 am
I think autism is a medical disease and not a behavioral or psychological problem. However, I also think behavioral therapies can be very helpful for quality of life. In my experience, most autistics are put in school settings where the “treatments” are behavior-based, and doctors and medicine are rarely in the picture. It’s a conundrum — we’re coping but not curing.
I don’t say this in any judgmental way. Our son is 18 and during most of those years, the best we could do was cope. But I think we owe it to future generations, including the children of our “normal” children who are now at greater risk of producing autistic offspring, to learn as much as we can about the medical aspects of autism. And to encourage our childrens’ doctors to do the same.
By: Deb on February 7, 2010
at 2:05 am
Well said, Jenny
By: Stickeenotes on February 8, 2010
at 3:49 am
They need to change the vaccine schedule. Both my sons have kanner’s autism. Both of them recieved 4 shots at one sitting when they were 18 pound toddlers.
FDA needs to do more group studies especially on military families. “Military families are most consistant with vaccine schedules”
By: jerry on February 13, 2010
at 9:55 am
I agree. I can’t see any negative to simply slowing down the vaccines schedule other than inconveniencing doctors.
I took my (non-autistic) daughter for her first checkup with our new family doctor this week. I purposely left her vaccine record at home. I’m not stopping vaccines for her or anything, I just kind of wanted to check this guy out before I let him do anything invasive.
I was really nervous about the whole topic of vaccines, but I stood my ground when it came up with the nurse and later with the doctor. I explained our situation and that I’m not anti-vaccine, but I might be a bit of a pain about getting multiple shots at one sitting and having to know exactly what was in any vaccines we get from now on. I was really pleasantly surprised. He said that approach sounded very sensible and basically “no problem”. It sucks CDC and AMA are giving guys like this such a bad rap.
By: killtruck on February 13, 2010
at 4:43 pm
I just wanted to say that I don’t have any kids (yet) and because of reading this I will be more informed when I do have kids. So thank you.
Actually maybe we will just have to have a “real” conversation about vaccines when that time comes.
with love
Aj
By: Aj Brown on May 1, 2010
at 9:59 pm
When the time comes you’re welcome to pick my brain if there’s anything left. Hopefully, they’ll have more answers by then.
By: killtruck on May 2, 2010
at 2:14 pm